Evaluation the Effect of different Cooling Cycles on the Hardness Surface of the Conventional Feldspathic Zirconia

Shahad Hazim Ali; Lateef Essa Alwan; Abdul Kareem J. Al-Azzawi

doi:10.51173/jt.v3i3.366

Authors

Shahad Hazim Ali College of Health and Medical Technology, Middle Technical University, Baghdad, Iraq
Lateef Essa Alwan Institute of Medical Technology Baghdad, Middle Technical University, Baghdad, Iraq
Abdul Kareem J. Al-Azzawi Al-Rasheed University Collage/ Dentistry Department, Baghdad, Iraq

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51173/jt.v3i3.366

Keywords:

Zirconia, Cooling Rate, Vickers Hardness (HV), Mechanical Properties, Scanning Electron Microscope, Crack

Abstract

Cooling rate is the main fact in success and life span of all ceramic restoration through its effect on mechanical properties and producing a residual tensile stress, crack propagation and failure restorations. The goals of this study is to assess the impact of diverse cooling cycles (slow cooling – fast cooling) on the surface hardness of the Zirconia (VM9). A total of 30 conventional Y-TZP Zirconia (Vita VM9) disks were fabricated according manufacturers recommendation. The samples were partition into three categories depending on the cooling system. Each group consisted of ten specimens in diameter (2mm×10mm). Control group: samples are unescorted by any change. Fast cooling group: these specimens were fast cooled after second firing (910C⁰ -600C⁰) with opening Oven muffle 25% withholding time for 5 minute and remove from the furnace to cool at room temperature. Slow cooling group: specimens were slow cooled after second firing (910C⁰ -400C⁰) with opening Oven muffle 25% withholding time for 5 minute and remove from the furnace to cool at room temperature. Each specimen was subjected to hardness test in load 9.8N at 15s using Digital microvickers Hardness tester, Scanning electron microscope. The statistical analysis revealed that, the highest vickers hardness mean value was for the control group (690.57 ± 69.9563) and for second group (618.12± 53.6164) and for third group (631.75±65.3858), The facts were statistically examined by applying ANOVA test (P- value) testes which revealed significant differences(p=0.038) (p<0.05) among groups. Conclusion: The impact of cooling cycle on the hardness surface measurements of the Zirconia (Vita VM9) between the three groups was significant. The slow cooling shows a higher value of (VH) Hardness and recommended for Zirconia than the fast cooling.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

KONTONASAKI, E., GIASIMAKOPOULOS, P. & RIGOS, A. E. “Strength and aging resistance of monolithic zirconia: an update to current knowledge”. Japanese Dental science Review, 56, 1-23. 2020.

ALKURT, M., DUYMUS, Z. Y. & GUNDOGDU, M. “Effects of multiple firings on the microstructure of zirconia and veneering ceramics”. Dental materials journal, 35, 776-781. 2016.

TRAINI, T., GHERLONE, E., PARABITA, S. F., CAPUTI, S. & PIATTELLI, A. “Fracture toughness and hardness of a Y-TZP dental ceramic after mechanical surface treatments”. Clinical in oral investigations, 18, 707-714. 2014.

LONGHINI, D., ROCHA, C. O. D. M., MEDEIROS, I. S., FONSECA, R. G. & ADABO, G. L. “Effect of glaze cooling rate on mechanical properties of conventional and pressed porcelain on zirconia”. Brazilian dental journals, 27, 524- 531. 2016.

TANG, Y. L., KIM, J.-H., SHIM, J.-S. & KIM, S. “The effect of different cooling rates and coping thicknesses on the failure load of zirconia-ceramic crowns after fatigue loading”. The journal of advanced prosthodontics , 9, 152. 2017.

ALZHRANI, A. M. & BADR, N. “Hardness and Fracture Toughness of Heat Pressable and Machinable Dental All-Ceramics”.

AL-WAHAB, Z. N. “An evaluation of the effects of different pH levels and multiple firing temperatures on hardness of ceramic”. Mustansiria Dental Journal 13. 2016.

HASAN, S. F. & ABOOD, A. Z. “Evaluation the effect of hydrofluoric acid and grinding treatment on shear bond strength of Ips e.max press with ceramic veneer material(in vitro study)”, 2017.

TAN, J. P., SEDERSTROM, D., POLANSKY, J. R., MCLAREN, E. A. & WHITE, S. N. “The use of slow heating and slow cooling regimens to strengthen porcelain fused to zirconia”. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry, 107, 163-169. 2012.

MARTíNEZ-GALEANO, G., BAUTISTA-LORA, A., PACHECO-MUñOZ, L. F. & GARZóN-RAYO, H. “Liner effect on the bond strength of feldspathic ceramic to zirconia using a slow cooling protocol”. Revista Facultad de Odontologia Universidad de Antioquia , 27, 63-75. 2015.

ABD KATI, F. & AL-KAABI, A. F. J. “Effect of oil paint addition on micro hardness of acrylic ocular prosthesis”. Iraqi Dental Journal , 38, 87-89. 2016.

DE CARVALHO, A. B. G., DAL PIVA, A. M. D. O., TRIBST, J. P. M., WERNER, A., SAAVEDRA, G. D. S. F. A. & KLEVERLAAN, C. J. “Effect of microwave crystallization on the wear resistance of reinforced glass- ceramics”. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 111, 104009. 2020.

MOHAMMED, B., AFRAM, B. & NAZAR, Z. “An evaluation of the effect of different surface treatment on hardness and smoothness of pressable ceramic (in vitro study)”. IOSR J Dent Med Sci IOSR , 14, 84-89. 2015.

CHEN, Y.-W., MOUSSI, J., DRURY, J. L. & WATAHA, J. C. “ Zirconia in biomedical applications”. Expert review of medical devices,13, 945-963. 2016.

BENAVENTE, R., SALVADOR, M., PENARANDA-FOIX, F. L., PALLONE, E. & BORRELL, A. “ Mechanical properties and microstructural evolution of alumina–zirconia nanocomposites by microwave sintering”. Ceramics International , 40, 11291-11297. 2014.

CHIN, C. H., MUCHTAR, A., AZHARI, C. H., RAZALI, M. & ABORAS, M. “ Influences of the processing method and sintering temperature on the translucency of polycrystalline yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia for dental applications”. Ceramics International 44, 18641-18649. 2018.

VASYLKIV, O., SAKKA, Y. & SKOROKHOD, V. V. “Low‐temperature processing and mechanical properties of zirconia and zirconia–alumina nanoceramics”. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 86, 299-304. 2003.

GAUTAM, C., JOYNER, J., GAUTAM, A., RAO, J. & VAJTAI, R. “Zirconia based dental ceramics: structure, mechanical properties, biocompatibility and applications”. Dalton transactions 45, 19194-19215. 2016.

AL-AMLEH, B., WADDELL, J. N., LYONS, K. & SWAIN, M. V.“Influence of veneering porcelain thickness and cooling rate on residual stresses in zirconia molar crowns”. Dental materials, 30, 271-280. 2014.

ALMEIDA-JúNIOR, A. A., LONGHINI, D., DOMINGUES, N. B., SANTOS, C. & ADABO, G. L.“Effects of extreme cooling methods on mechanical properties and shear bond strength of bilayered porcelain/3Y-TZP specimens”. Journal of dentistry, 41, 356-362. 2013.

DENRY, I. & HOLLOWAY, J. “Microstructural and crystallographic surface changes after grinding zirconia‐based dental ceramics”.

Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials: An Official Journal of the society for Biomaterials, the Japanese society for biomaterials, and the Australian society for biomaterials and the Korean society for biomaterials , 76, 440-448. 2006.

CANDIDO, L., MIOTTO, L., FAIS, L., CESAR, P. & PINELLI, L. “Mechanical and surface properties of monolithic zirconia”.Operative dentistr, 43, E119-E128. 2018.

HARADA, K., SHINYA, A., YOKOYAMA, D. & SHINYA, A. “Effect of loading conditions on the fracture toughness of zirconia”. Journal of prosthodontic research, 57, 82-87. 2013.