Biomechanical Investigation of the Efficacy of Conventional Bicycle Helmets at Preventing Facial Injury

Ghaidaa A. Khalid

doi:10.51173/jt.v4i4.867

Authors

Ghaidaa A. Khalid Electrical Engineering Technical College, Middle Technical University, Baghdad, Iraq.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51173/jt.v4i4.867

Keywords:

Biomechanics, Facial Injury, Bicycle-Helmet, Medical Instrumentation

Abstract

Many studies indicate that wearing a bicycle helmet significantly reduces the risk of accident-related head injuries. Less is reported, however, about bicycle helmet use, about preventing facial injury. Epidemiological studies typically report incidences of 'head injury,' though rarely categorize head, brain, and facial injuries separately. Studies that do focus on facial injury suggest that helmets do not provide adequate protection. A 3D biofidelic child head form and two conventional bicycle helmets (that is,” open face") were created in MSC ADAMS™ computer modelling and simulation software. Peak force and linear accelerations were measured for a series of head form impact simulations corresponding to an established testing standard and a newly proposed series of tests derived from modified motorcycle standards, incorporating injury thresholds from the facial bone impact tolerance literature. Almost all impact simulations exceeded the threshold for fracture, soft tissue, and dental trauma. An observational study was conducted using MSC ADAMS™ to assess a helmeted headform's face exposure during impact simulations. Helmets failed to reduce face impact exposure, during all simulations, except for perpendicular cheek impacts. International test standards, therefore, require urgent revision to ensure that face protection is included.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

R. Elvik, “Publication bias and time-trend bias in meta-analysis of bicycle helmet efficacy: A re-analysis of Attewell, Glase, and McFadden”, 2001 Accident Analysis and Prevention, vol.43, pp.1245–51,2011.

D. Thompson, R. Thompson, F. Rivara, M. Wolf, “A case-control study of the effectiveness of bicycle safety helmets in preventing facial injury”, American Journal of Public Health, vol.80, No.12, pp.1471- 4, 1990.

M. Harrison, J. Shepherd, “The circumstances and scope for prevention of maxillofacial injuries in cyclists”, Journal of the Royal College of Surgeons Edinburgh, vol.44, pp.82-6, 1999.

H. Chapman, A. Curran, “Bicycle helmets - does the dental profession have a role in promoting their use? ”, British Dental Journal, vol.196, pp.555 – 60, 2004.

C. Illingwort, D. Noble, D. Bell, I. Kemn, J. Pascoe, “150 bicycle injuries in children: a comparison with accidents due to other causes”. Journal of Injury, vol.13. No.1, pp.7-9,1981.

J. Worrell, “Head injuries in pedal cyclists: how much will protection help? ”, Injury, vol.18, pp.5-6.

C. Lindquist, S. Sorsa, T. Hyrkas, S. Santavirta, “Maxillofacial injuries sustained in bicycle accidents”, International Journal of Oral Maxillofacial Surgery, vol.15, pp.12-18, 1987.

C. Illingwort, D. Noble, D. Bell, I. Kemn, J. Pascoe, “150 bicycle injuries in children: a comparison with accidents due to other causes”. Journal of Injury, vol.13. No.1, pp.7-9,1981.

J. Dickson, P. Theobald, M. Jones, “Do children wearing bicycle helmets increase their risk of sustaining a brain injury?”, International Society of Biomechanics, Brussels, Belgium, 2011.

V. St Clair, B. Chinn, “Assessment of Current Bicycle Helmets for the Potential to Cause Rotational Injury”. Project Report PPR 213, Berkshire: Transport Research Laboratories Limited, 2007.

British Standards Institution. BS EN 1078:1997. “Helmets for pedal cyclists and users of Skateboards and roller skates”. London: BSI.

N. Yoganandan, F. Pintar, “Biomechanics of temporo-parietal skull fracture”, Clinical Biomechanics, vol. 19, pp. 225–392004.

M. Kleinberger, E. Sun, R. Eppinger, S. Kuppa, R. Saul, “Development of Improved Injury Criteria for the Assessment of Advanced Automotive Restraint Systems”, National Highways Traffic Safety Administration Docket No 1998, pp.4405-9,1998.

D. Mohan, B. Bowman, R. Snyder, D. Foust, “A biomechanical analysis of head impact injuries to children”. American Society of Mechanical Engineering”, vol.101, pp.250-260, 1977.

N. Yoganandan, S. Kumaresan, F. Pintar, T. Gennarelli, “Pediatric biomechanics”. In: Nahum A, Melvin J editor. 2000. Accidental Injury: Biomechanics and Prevention. New York: Springler-Verlag, pp.550–87.

G. Nyquist, J. Cavanaugh, S. Goldberg, A. King, “Facial Impact Tolerance and Response”. in Conf. Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, 1986, vol.30, pp.379-400.

V. Hodgson, L. Thomas, “Breaking strength of the human skull vs. impact surface curvature”. Wayne State University School of Medicine. Detroit, MI. National Highways Traffic Safety Administration DOT-H-S-801- 002, PB 233041,1971.

C. Gadd, “Use of a weighted-impulse criterion for estimating injury hazard”. in Conf. Proceedings of the 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference, Coronado, CA, 1966, pp.164-174.

D. Allsop, C. Warner, M. Wille, D. Schneider, A. Nahum, “Facial Impact Response - A Comparison of the Hybrid III Dummy and Human Cadaver”, in Conf. Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, 1988, vol. 32, pp. 139-55.

A. Nahum, “The prediction of maxillofacial trauma”. Trans American Academy of Opthalmology and Otoloryngology, vol. 84, pp.932-3, 1976.

D. Schneider, A. Nahum, “Impact studies of facial bones and skull”. In Proceedings of the 16th Stapp Car Crah Conference Society of Automotive Engineers No 720965, 1972, pp. 186-204.

D. Hampson, “Facial Injury: A review of biomechanical studies and test procedures for facial injury assessment”. Journal of Biomechanics, vol. 28, No.1, pp.1-2,1995.

M. Craig, C. Bir, D. Viano, S. Tashman, “Biomechanical response of the human mandible to impacts of the chin”, Journal of Biomechanics, vol. 41, pp.2972–80, 2008.

J. Melvin, W. Little, J. Smrcka, Y. Zhu, M. Salloum, “A Biomechanical Face for the Hybrid III Dummy”. in Conf. Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, 1995, vol.39, pp.140-51.

G.A. Khalid, R. Prabhu, J. Dickson, et al. “Biomechanical engineering investigation of the risk of children wearing a bicycle helmet suffering an angular acceleration induced head injury”, MOJ Sports Med, vol.1, No.5, pp.109-115, 2017. DOI: 10.15406/mojsm.2017.01.00025

T. Garlie, S. Saunders, “Midline facial tissue thickness of sub adults from longitudinal radiographic study”. Journal of Forensic Science, vol. 30, No. 4, pp. 1100–2, 1985.

M. Williamson, S. Nawrocki, T. Rathbun, “Variation in midfacial tissue thickness of African-American children”, Journal of Forensic Science, vol. 47, No.1, pp. 25–31, 2002.

H. Utsuno, T. Kageyama, K. Uchida, M. Yoshino, H. Miyazawa, K. Inoue, “Facial soft tissue thickness in Japanese children”. Forensic Science International, vol.199, No.(1-3), pp. 1-6, 2010.

G. Suazo, L. Cantin, M. Zavando, R. Perez, M. Torres, “Comparisons in soft-tissue thicknesses on the human face in fresh and embalmed corpses using needle puncture method”. International Journal of Morphology, vol. 26, No.1, pp. 165-9, 2008.

R. Sivamani, J. Goodman, N. Gitis, H. Maibach, “Friction coefficient of skin in real-time”, Skin Research and Technology, vol. 9, No.3, pp.235–9, 2003.

M. Zhang, A. Mak, “In vivo friction properties of human skin”, Prosthetics and Orthotics Int. l, vol.23, pp.135–41, 1999.

G. Elert, “Coefficients of Friction for Human Skin” [online]. Available at: http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2005/skin.shtml [Accessed: 11 March 2010].

British Standards Institution. BS 6658:1985. “Protective helmets for vehicle users”. London BSI.

Snell Memorial Foundation - standard for helmets for use in childrens motor [Online]. Available at:http://www.smf.org/standards/cmh/cm2007booklet_final.pdf >[Accessed 9 Feb. 2011].

Snell Memorial Foundation - Standard for Motorcycle helmets M2010 [Online]. Available at: http://www.smf.org/standards/m/2010/m2010_final_booklet.pdf > [Accessed 9 Feb. 2011].

Snell Memorial Foundation - Addendum to cycle helmet standard B95 1998 [Online]. Available at: http://www.smf.org/standards/pdf/1998_cpsc_c_addendum_to_b90_b95.pdf>[Accessed 9 Feb. 2011]

Snell Memorial Foundation - Revised standard for cycle helmets B95 1995 [Online]. Available at: http://www.smf.org/standards/pdf/b95rev.pdf >[Accessed 9 Feb. 2011].

H. Reynolds, C. Clauser, J. McConville, R. Chandler, J. Young, “Mass distribution properties of the male cadaver”, Highway Safety Research Institute. Society of Automotive Engineers Transactions 750424, pp.1148–50,1975.

P. Löwenhielm, “Mathematical simulations of gliding contusions”. Journal of Biomechanics, vol. 8, pp.351–6, 1975.

B. Depreitere, C. Van Lierde, J. Vander Sloten, R. Van Audekercke, G. Van Der Perre, C. Plets, J. Goffin, “Mechanics of acute subdural hematomas resulting from bridging vein rupture”, Journal of Neurosurgery, vol. 104, pp.950-6, 2006.

M.D. Jones, D. Darwall, G. Khalid, R. Prabhu, A.Kemp, O. Arthurs, P. Theobald. “Development and validation of a physical model to investigate the biomechanics of infant head impact”, Forensic science international, vol. 276, pp.111-119, 2017.

G.A. Khalid, R.K. Prabhu, O. Arthurs, M.D. Jones, “A coupled physical-computational methodology for the investigation of short fall related infant head impact injury”, Forensic science international, vol. 300, pp. 170-186, 2019.

M.D. Jones, G.A. Khalid, R.K. Prabhu, “Chapter 11 - Development of a coupled physical–computational methodology for the investigation of infant head injury”, in Multiscale Biomechanical Modeling of the Brain, R.K. Prabhu, M. Horstemeyer, Academic Press, 2022, pp. 177-192.

J. Melvin, T. Shee, “Facial injury assessment techniques”, in Conf. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles, 1989.

D. Kim, M. Sacapano, R. Hardesty, “Facial Fractures in Children. Epitomes of Plastic Surgery”. Western J Med, vol. 167, No.2, 1997.

O. Lieger, J. Zix, A. Kruse, T. Lizuka, “Dental Injuries in Association with Facial Fractures”. J Oral Maxillofacial Surgery, vol. 67, pp.1680-4, 2009.

D. Otte, “Injury mechanism and crash kinematics of bicyclists in accidents”. in Conf. Proceedings of the 33rd Stapp car crash conference, Society of Automotive Engineers paper 892425, 1989.

B. Plaisier, A. Punjabi, D. Super, R. Haug, “The relationship between facial fractures and death from neurologic injury”. Journal of Oral Maxillofacial Surgery, vol.58, No.7, pp. 708-12, 2000.

G.S. Nusholtz, D. E. Huelke, P. Lux. N. M. Alem and F. Montalvo, Cervical Spine Injury Mechanisms. SAE paper, 831616,1983.

G.A. Khalid, H. Bakhtiarydavijani, W.R. Whittington, R. Prabhu, M.D. Jones. “Material response characterization of three poly jet printed materials used in a high fidelity human infant skull”, in Conf. Materials Today: Proceedings 20, 408-413,2020.

G.A. Khalid, “Density and Mechanical Properties of Selective Silicon Materials to Produce 3D Printed Paediatric Brain Model”, Materials Science Forum, vol. 1021, pp. 221, 2021.